Jens Oliver Meiert

On Enforcing Coding Guidelines

Post from October 2, 2017 (↻ August 22, 2018), filed under .

Surprisingly a snippet from The Little Book of Website Quality Control, not the one of HTML/CSS coding guidelines, a few thoughts on enforcing coding standards.

In the context of coding guidelines, we’ve learned to differentiate between descriptive or positive guidelines and those that are prescriptive or normative […]. The difference is mostly practical—when code quality is at a high level, we merely document (describe) what everyone’s already doing; when code quality is low, we tell everyone what to do (prescribe). However, as it pertains to much of what we’ve discussed so far, this requires some way of enforcement.

The cover of “The Little Book of Website Quality Control.”

How do we enforce quality? This is still a difficult question; so difficult, in fact, that in practice we often see it dodged. Why? Because enforcement easily upsets people, and we don’t want to upset people, not even […] when they report to us. But we’re on the right track here.

Enforcement happens top-down. Executives and managers are to be looked at to emphasize and live quality, to reward good quality, and to—in one way or another—discourage poor quality. How? By doing what we surprisingly forget frequently: measuring quality and tying related metrics to performance evaluations.

Two anecdotes illustrate that approach. There’s one tale of a manager who has, despite efforts of his team to up the ante and increase quality in his department, never endorsed, let alone supported or encouraged those team members’ efforts in team communications or goals. That quality initiative’s efforts, witnessed at one point at a major corporation, suffered a significant blowback.

At the same firm at another time, managers called out the importance of quality and used available data points, like performance scores as measured by Google’s PageSpeed tools, accessibility problems as measured by Sidar’s HERA, or the number of validation errors as measured by W3C’s Link Checker. Although the team in question never got to tie metrics like these to performance evaluations, that precise step was on the table as to [mean] strong encouragement and—ultimately enforce—higher quality.

It’s not my best book, and the overview of tools is not aging well (better consult, but I maintain the idea that there still are a few useful things to be picked up.

About the Author

Jens Oliver Meiert, photo of September 22, 2018.

Jens Oliver Meiert is an author and developer (O’Reilly, W3C, ex-Google). He plays with philosophy, art, and adventure. Here on he shares and generalizes and exaggerates some of his thoughts and experiences.

There’s more Jens in the archives and at Goodreads. If you have any questions or concerns (or recommendations) about what he writes, leave a comment or a message.

Read More

Have a look at the most popular posts, possibly including:

Say hello on Twitter or LinkedIn.

Looking for a way to comment? Comments have been disabled, unfortunately.

Found a mistake? Email me,

You are here: HomeArchive2017 → On Enforcing Coding Guidelines

Last update: August 22, 2018

Awareness, honesty, responsibility.